X&Y - Recensionde del NME

[Betaray]

Coldplay : X&Y



This album cannot fail. That is a bald statement of fact. If ‘X&Y’ does not break eight figures, then EMI– Britain’s last free-standing major record label –will fall into inexorable decline, the World Bank will foreclose on the British government and massive tracts of Norfolk and Cornwall will crumble into the sea. It’s a remarkable thing, but with an artist as fantastically self-critical and flaky as Chris Martin, his label still decided it was a good idea to issue a profit warning to the stock-market because his band’s new album was a few weeks late.

The label quickly denied it, of course, and insisted it was also down to other parts of their business needing to perform – Coldplay’s tardiness was just a minor part in the blip. But that’s codswallop. You do the sums – ‘A Rush Of Blood To The Head’ sold 11 million copies. When Coldplay were late with this one, the label got the shits and fired a shot across the bows.

How Chris Martin must have loved that. So it is that this has become the most anticipated third album since Oasis’ ‘Be Here Now’. It’s now the main talking point of the record industry, of the stock market and, somewhere down the line, of fans.

And because of the interest, the label have thrown together a containment and secrecy operation that makes the Opus Dei look like a transparent, all-embracing force for enlightenment (let them sue – I have a good priest).
To get this CD to NME, the label employed a special envoy who flew with a sealed parcel to Belfast where it was slowly slipped over the table in a city centre hotel. The name Coldplay appeared nowhere – it was marked simply ‘The Fir Trees album’ and even the track titles were adjusted. NME had to sign to a letter promising not to let anyone look at the record pre-release, never mind hear it, on pain of a slow, medieval death.

All this meant one of two things. Either the label felt they had one of the all-time great albums on their hands and would do anything to stop it leaking early onto the web. Or they had been sold a pup and were undertaking a brilliant marketing manoeuvre to make everyone think it was one of the all-time great albums.

Since ‘A Rush Of Blood To The Head’, there have been very obvious changes to Coldplay’s life. There’s the Hollywood star wife, the baby, Chris Martin emerging as a surprisingly effective anti-paparazzi punch-thrower. But equally as telling are the similarities between life around the recording of that one and of ‘X&Y’. Again, exhausted after a relentless, punishing tour, Coldplay had to sit down and decide if they still wanted to be a band. Having sold more than anyone ever dreamed, broken bigger in America than thought possible for a British band, they decided to retreat and come up with something even more mighty than before – to reinvent the wheel, as Chris Martin must now regret saying.

Have they succeeded? Well, there are no tracks on ‘X&Y’ as immediate as ‘The Scientist’ or ‘In My Place’ or ‘Yellow’. It takes time to seep in and get to you. But then – and its easy to forget – ‘A Rush Of Blood…’wasn’t immediate either. Those songs might feel like part of the fabric now and that record might have opened with the slam-dunk of ‘Politik’ but it was an album that took a lot of listens.

Here, ‘Square One’ picks up where ‘Politik’ left off. It’s Coldplay doing Radiohead, hoking round the studio for new sounds and shapes. It starts quietly before Chris chimes in with that broken glass voice, now as identifiable as any in music, and Johnny Buckland works through The Edge’s collection of effects pedals. It’s about cracking puzzles and codes, solving riddles – a recurring Coldplay obsession. It’s about this record – once you get it, it makes perfect sense - and its about Chris Martin.

Lucky for Coldplay and for us he remains riddled with self-doubt. He also remains absolutely intangible. The more he says and the more that is revealed about him, the less sense he makes. There were stories about Martin putting in 18-hourdays to get this record right. There were stories at the same time about problems at home and much of this album could easily by read as an open letter to his wife. ‘What If’, with its cry of ‘What if you don’t want me there by your side/What if you don’t want me there in the light’ is, on the face of it, a simple message to Gwyneth Paltrow. The gentle, pulsing big ballad backing does little to change the idea. But that’s too obvious and too trite for Martin. It’s no leap to see it as a message to fans. Martin, ever the pessimist, is unsure if he has pushed things too far, if Coldplay have been front and centre too long and if he might lose the muse and never write another word or note of worth.

This nagging doubt is at the core of ‘X&Y’. It’s a record about how we end up with the perfect one and the fear of keeping that intangible light burning. It’s also about a bunch of middle class boys lucking out, creating alchemy and becoming the biggest band of their generation while still scared shitless they’ll end up working in a call centre. It’s a brilliant record of paranoia. Oasis third album was an overblown opus to the excesses of cocaine and the good-life. Radiohead’s was a claustrophobic, intense look at the end of the world. Coldplay ’s is about love and fear. When ‘Fix You’ kicks in, which NME will concede must be about Paltrow (‘Tears stream down your face/When you lose something you can’t replace… and I will fix you’), it’s an old-fashioned hair on the neck moment. It’s a wonderful song that shifts from simple stark piano and voice to a ringing, clattering burst of intent and proto-prog four-part harmony. It will become a massive live track. Elsewhere, you don’t have to dig too deep to find the influences Coldplay have mined. There’s the Kraftwerk lift (from ‘Computer Love’) on ‘Talk’, a nod to Prince’s ‘When Doves Cry’ on ‘White Shadows’, some Lennon-driven Beatles rocking through on ‘A Message’ and Echo & The Bunnymen here and there. They even sneak in ‘Til Kingdom Come’, the song they wrote for Johnny Cash that he never got to record, as a simple acoustic secret track.

But it is U2, now Coldplay’s natural peers, who loom largest of all. Their shadow falls on every note, in the complete confidence the band have playing together– and Buckland is not backward about emulating The Edge on half a dozen tracks. Confident, bold, ambitious, bunged with singles and impossible to contain, ‘X&Y’ doesn’t reinvent the wheel but it does reinforce Coldplay as the band of their time. The MD of Parlophone and his shareholders can sleep easy. This is a great, great record that has just raised the bar for everyone. That’s probably of little consequence for Chris Martin. The worries for our great self-doubting hero about how to better it start now.

Paul McNamee
Rating: 9

[Betaray]

insomma capolavoro e nuovi U2
Martin prossimo papa
e noi tutti a comprare il cd

az

[la_diarrea]

insomma capolavoro e nuovi U2
Martin prossimo papa
e noi tutti a comprare il cd

az

quello degli oasis quando lo recensiscono?

di solito 9 o 10 a chi hanno dato?

[Betaray]

10 e raro
9 un po' meno tutti igli album dei giocofreddo han preso 9
comunque tutto pè realtivo

[Starframe]

Recensioni dell'NME per gli Oasis:

DM 9
WTSMG 7
BHN 8
TM 9
SOTSOG 6
HC 8

[la_diarrea]

Recensioni dell'NME per gli Oasis:

DM 9
WTSMG 7
BHN 8
TM 9
SOTSOG 6
HC 8

ho capito che non capiscono un cazzo

[grievance]

io l'unico 10 che ho visto sul sito dell'nme tra le recensioni
è quello dato a "is this it" degli strokes
GIUSTISSIMO!!!!!!!!!
ma per me anche Definitely maybe è 10

[grievance]

ma l'nme quando farà uscire la recensione di DBTT??????

[flavio85]

Recensioni dell'NME per gli Oasis:

DM 9
WTSMG 7
BHN 8
TM 9
SOTSOG 6
HC 8

ho capito che non capiscono un cazzo

quoto alla grande hc 8 wtsmg 7 sotsog 6................

[The Shield]

Recensioni dell'NME per gli Oasis:

DM 9
WTSMG 7
BHN 8
TM 9
SOTSOG 6
HC 8

ma a Povia allora gli danno 10...
6 a sotsog è indecente se confrontato al 7 di wtsmg e all 8 di hc.
come si fa a dire che hc è meglio di wtsmg?